Hashim Maroof Husayni about Kulayni


Shia scholar Hashim Maroof Husayni in his book “Dirasatun fil Hadith wal Muhadithin” (p 192) said:

( . . .ولكن الكليني مع أخطائه الكثيرة لم يشذ شذوذ البخاري . . . )

Translation:

….but Kulayni along with his MANY MISTAKES, didn’t make odd things like oddities of Bukhari…

Discussion:

Words of Rafidi against Bukhari doesn’t hold any weight in our view, and for sure can’t harm reputation of Bukhari in any way.

But words of Rafidi about their own top hadith scholar means a lot. Here we see clearly admission of rafidi that his major hadith scholar did MANY MISTAKES.

Originally posted: http://alsrdaab.com/vb/showthread.php?t=60685

1 Comment

  1. Ali Shah Hussain

    But it does prove the jealousy of the Rafadi scholar against Imam Bukhari(r.a).
    Brother Efendi yours this point is perfect one…….”Here we see clearly admission of rafidi that his major hadith scholar did MANY MISTAKES”………….lol

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 877 other followers

%d bloggers like this: