Category Archives: FADAK, Fatimah & Abu Bakr

Khomeini too says Prophets do NOT leave inheritance … [FADAK]

Unfortunately Shias (including their scholars) are often so blinded in their hatred towards the Sahaba that they forget their own books and verdicts. Take for instance Abu Bakr dispute with Fatimah (رضوان الله عليهما) in regards to the former Jewish land of Fadak. They do not just accuse Abu Bakr of denying Fatimah’s so called …

Continue reading

Imam Zaynalabidin on Fadak

Bismillah. Salam alaikum. Imam Beyhaki narrated in his book al-Itiqad (p 497), with chain of upright narrators, that Imam of Ahlalbayt, Ali ibn Hussayn said: As for me, if I will be on the place of Abu Bakr, I will rule as he did in the issue of Fadak. Scan page:

Continue reading

Did the events of Karbala actually take place, and if so why do we not mention this event and the massacre in our Khutbas?

A Sunni who is influenced by what the Raafidis say and is confused about what is true and correct Did the events of Karbala actually take place, and if so why do we not mention this event and the massacre of the Prophets grandson and his children in our Khutbas? Also did the Prophet not …

Continue reading

Fadak Area Between Abu Bakr and Fatimah

by Muhammad Al-Khider FADAK is a hamlet in Hijaz that used to be inhabited by a group of Jews. After Rasulullah had accomplished the conquest of Khaybar, Allah cast fear into the hearts of those Jews.They therefore conclude a treaty with Rasulullah in terms of which Fadak was ceded to him. Thus, not having been …

Continue reading

The Ahl Al-Bayt never accused Abu Bakr of having usurped Fatimah’s right, some even sided with him word for word

The final coffin in all those Fadak related debates, the following should be enough for every Muslim, no need for hours of debates, just take the stance of the Ahl Al-Bayt:

Continue reading

The ignorance of Al-Mufid and Muhaqiq about their own books! (FADAK related)

Bismillah. Salam Alaikum. I’d like to share with small observation from the book of one of the top shia shaykhs known as Mufid. In his book “Risala hawla hadith Nahnu Muasharul Anbiya la Nuwarith” (page 4), thk: Malik al-Mahmudi, al-Mufid said:

Continue reading

Inheritance in the Qur’an (Fadak related)

By brother Farid: Bismillah alrahman alraheem, The follow is some material from a very useful book called Difa’an ‘an Al-Aal wal As’haab (p. 260). It goes without saying that this was originally in Arabic, but it was so useful to me, that I could not help but translate some of the content. I will be …

Continue reading

Ali stance on Fadak

Shaykh of shias al-Murtada in his book “ash-Shafi fil Imama” (4/92) said: ان الامر لما انتهى الى امير المؤمنين عليه السلام – اي علي رضي الله عنه – ترك فدك على ماكانت عليه – أي في عهد ابي بكر وعمر رضوان الله عليهما – ولم يجعلها ميراثا ولد فاطمة عليها السلام Translation: When ruling passed …

Continue reading

Few interesting reports from “Fadhail as-sahaba” of Daraqutni (AHL AL-BAYT LOVED THE SHAYKHAYN)

Few interesting reports from “Fadhail as-sahaba” of Daraqutni. Darul Majid Asiriya. #74 via double chain one till ibn Abi Umar and second till Uqba ibn Mukaram, both of them reported from Sufyan, which narrated from Jafar ibn Muhammad as-Sadiq, which reported that his father Muhammad al-Baqir said: “Family (Ali) of Abu Bakr in the time …

Continue reading

Narration: Abu Bakr said testfied his regret in regards to what he did to Fatimah

Athar: Abu Bakr said ‘I did three things that I now regret, they are: That I failed to show respect towards the house of Fatima……. Famous Rafidi AA site wrote following: Abu Bakr said ‘I did three things that I now regret, they are: That I failed to show respect towards the house of Fatima. …

Continue reading

Sunni Hadeeth: The Prophet gave Fadak as a gift to Fatima? (another Shia excuse)

Hadeeth: Prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa ala alihi wa sallam) gave fadak as gift to Fatima (r.a). It was narrated from Abu Saeed al-Hudri that after Allah revealed verse (surah al-Isra, 26 )“And give to the near of kin his due and (to) the needy and the wayfarer, and do not squander wastefully”, prophet (sallalahu alaihi …

Continue reading

Doubt: Shia arguments from the Qur’an in relation to inhertance (FADAK)

Salam alaikum, in one from our previous posts, we have already talked about Fadak in details. In their attempt to make any base for their position, shias trying to find a proof in the verses of Quran. And usually, they are bringing this one. “And Sulaiman inherited Dawood…” Naml 27 : 16(Part) First of all we …

Continue reading

Fadak – Prophet certainly do not inheritance according to Sunni and Shia books

Regarding narration, that there is no inheritance from prophets. Kattani in “Nazmul mutanaseera min al hadeethal mutawateera” (272) wrote: “Narration that no one inherits from prophets, everything that they leave behind is for charity Suyooti in “Azhar” reported it via: 1) Umar. 2) Uthmaan. 3) Ali. 4) Sad ibn Abi Vaqas 5) Abbas. 6) Abu Bakr. …

Continue reading

What does Al Kulaini say in his book?

Al-Kulaini states in his al-Kafi: “That the Imams know the times of their deaths, and that they only die if they so wish”[1].  And we find al-Majlisi – in his ‘Bihar al-Anwar’ – mentioning a hadith which says: “None of the Imams died a natural death; each of them was either killed or poisoned”[2]. Now, if …

Continue reading

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,002 other followers