Hadeeth: “My hand and `Ali’s are equal when it comes to justice.”


Hadeeth: “My hand and `Ali’s are equal when it comes to justice.”

Abdulhussain al-Mosawi gave it as hadith #27, in the letter #48 of his book.

This hadith was narrated from Hubsha ibn Janada. Shaykhana Albani said it’s invented in his “Silsila ad-daeefa” #4897, same opinion shared ibn Jawzi in his “Ilal al-mutanahiyah” (1/213).

Ibn Asakir narrated it in his history (42/369). In the chain Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn  Salih at-Tammar. Dhahabi said that he narrated fabricated story (discussed one) with reference to ibn Warat. (“Mugni fi duafa” #425; “Mizanul itidal” 1/146/#570).