Majlisi: Mufid and Kulayni did believe in tahrif


Whoever browsed our blog, especially section Shia vs Quran seen a lot of evidences that greatest shia scholars believed in corruption in Quran.

We have seen Fani Isfahani, Faydh Kashani and Tayeb Jazairi saying that Kulayni did believe in tahrif in Quran.

Let me add another testimony against Kulayni and add other shia giant al-Mufid.

The one who is testifying against them is Muhammad Baqir al-Majlisi.

In his book “Miratul Uqul” he said:

و اختلف أصحابنا في ذلك، فذهب الصدوق ابن بابويه و جماعة إلى أن القرآن لم يتغير عما أنزل و لم ينقص منه شي‏ء، و ذهب الكليني و الشيخ المفيد قدس الله روحهما و جماعة إلى أن جميع القرآن عند الأئمة عليهم السلام، و ما في المصاحف بعضه، و جمع أمير المؤمنين صلوات الله عليه كما أنزل بعد الرسول صلى الله عليه و آله و سلم و أخرج إلى الصحابة المنافقين فلم يقبلوا منه

“And our companions differed in this matter (tahrif in Quran). As-Saduq ibn Babaveyh al-Qummi and group hold opinion that Quran is exactly in such form as it was revealed, nothing changed or omitted from it. And Kulayni with sheikh Mufid … and group turned to opinion that gathered Quran with imams (alaihuma salam), as for the (verses) in mushaf it’s (only) some of it, and commander of faithful (salawatullah alaihi) gathered (Quran) as it was revealed after prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa ala alihi wa sallam) and brought it to hypocrites companions, which didn’t accept it from him…”.

Source: “Miratul uqul” 3/30