Lie from Ali al-Milani


In his book “Daleel al-aqli ala imamah Ali” ( p 27-28) gave as a proof for shias views, hadith: Ali is best judge among them.

He said:

ويقول رسول الله ( صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم ) :  أقضاكم علي

And prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa ala alihi wa sallam) said: Best judge among them is Ali.

http://www.rafed.net/books/aqaed/aldalil-alaqli/02.html

As you can see, he claimed that this hadith present in the books: Saheeh al-Bukhari, Musnad Ahmad, Mustadrak, Sunnan ibn Majah, Tabaqat al-Kubra, Istiyab, Sunnan Beyhaki, Majmau zawaid, Hilliyah, Usudul-Ghaba, ar-Riyadh an-Nadeera and others.

BUT HE LIED (Is any one surprised?)

These words were reported by ibn Sad in “Tabaqat” (2/339,340), by Ahmad in “Musnad” (5/113), Bukhari in his “Saheeh” (5/149) AS WORDS OF UMAR, AND NOT AS ELEVATED HADITH TILL PROPHET (SALLALAHU ALAIHI WA ALA ALIHI WA SALLAM)!

Ibn Majah narrated from Anas ibn Malik in his “Sunnan” (#154), that prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa ala alihi wa sallam) said: “Most merciful in my nation towards my nation is Abu Bakr, most severe between them in religious matters Umar, most truthful Uthman, best judge from them  is Ali, best reciter of Allah’s book in Ubay ibn Kab, most knowledgeable in halal and haram Muaz ibn Jabal, most knowledgeable in matters of inheritance is Zayd ibn Sabit. Attention! Each nation had his own Ameen (trusty), and the trusty of this nation is Abu Ubaydah ibn al-Jarrah”.

We can ask this dajal al-Milani. Does he consider this hadith as saheeh? If yes, he should be honest and quote it in complete form. But this dajal took a part of hadith, and omitted unnecessary part for him.

 

 

 

 

2 thoughts on “Lie from Ali al-Milani

  1. Salam Alaikum brother. I showed this to shias, they said that

    Milani didn’t say that “And prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa ala alihi wa sallam) said: Best judge among them is Ali.” present in in “Tabaqat”, “Musnad”, “Saheeh”.

    Milani said: وحديث « أقضاكم علي » تجدونه في :

    The tradition “Best judge among them is Ali” present in these books:

    Meaning these words present in these books.

    • Alaikuma Salam.
      Akhi first he said that it is from prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa sallam), then he said – The tradition “Best judge among them is Ali” present in these books. He didn’t make clear that if these words is from Umar or prophet, he didn’t mention Umar at all. So ask shias to present this hadith from words of prophet from mentioned books.

Comments are closed.