Irshad al-Qulub – another alteration?


Once upon a time there was a shia scholar and his name was al-Hasan ibn Abul Hasan ad-Daylami. In his book “Irshad al-Qulub” (see scans) he said:

Majlisi mentioned in volume 9 of his book Bihar al-Anwar, and Sayeed al-Bahrani in the book “al-Madinatul Majaiz”…

Someone could say: So what? One shia narrated from other.

But the problem is:

1) ad-Daylami died in 841 h, as said Muhsin al-Ameen.

2) Majlisi died in 1111 h.

3) Bahrani died in 1107 or 1109.

2 thoughts on “Irshad al-Qulub – another alteration?

  1. Salamun Alaikum. May Allah (SWT), His Rasul (S.) and his vicegerents (A.) be pleased with you. May I get a soft copy of the book “Irshad Al-Qulub”. I am in need of it. If it is is in English it would be more convenient.

    Thanking you with best regards.

    Rashed
    22-11-2011

Comments are closed.