Shahrudi and elementary arithmetic


:Bismillah:

Nice discover from brother from forum alsrdaab.

Shia shaykh Ali an-Namazi ash-Shahrudi in “Mustadrakat ilmul rijal al-hadith” (1/15) said regarding abul Hasan al-Awwal al-Musa al-Kadhim:

ولد بالأبواء بين مكة والمدينة في سنة ١٢٨ – ١٢٩
Was born in al-Abwa between Mecca and Medina in 128 – 129 H.

In the same book volume 8, p 205, ash-Shahrudi was discussing narrator Yahya ibn Zayd ibn Ali ibn Hussayn.

He said regarding him (من أصحاب الصادق والكاظم ) (from companions of Saduq and al-Kadhim) and few sentences further at next page he said: (مقتله وشهادته في سنة ١٢٥) (his death and shahadah happen in 125)

Imam was born in 128 – 129, and his companion died in 125? Weird isn’t it?