Hidden proofs for Imamah!


Muhaqiq al-Hilli said, as it is in the book of ayatullat Ridha Ustadi “Rasail al-Muhaqiq al-Hilli” p 399;400, said:

رسائل المحقق الحلي ـ الاية رضا الاستادي ص400 - Copy.JPG

الوجه الثاني : على إمامته فيجب أن يكون إماما.
أما النص عليه فقسمان جلي وخفي أما الجلي فما نقلته الشيعة خلفا عن سلف إلى النبي عليه السلام من نصه عليه بالامامة نصا لا يحتمل التأويل ….
وأما الخفي فقوله عليه السلام : (من كنت مولاه فعلي مولاه اللهم وال من والاه وعاد من عاداه وانصر من نصره واخذل من خذله وأدر الحق معه كيف ما دار.
وقوله عليه السلام : أنت مني بمنزلة هارون من موسى.
وقوله لجماعة من أصحابه : اللهم ائتني بأحب الناس إليك يأكل معي.

Translation:

Second thing: Regarding his Imamah and that he has to be an Imam. What is regarding nass upon him, there are two types: clear and hidden. As for regarding clear one  – they are proofs been narrated by later shias from their pious ancestors, till messenger (alaihi salam), from his indications, that couldn’t be interpreted (in other way)…… 

As for HIDDEN proofs that is saying of alaihi salam: “To whom ever I am mawla, Ali is his mawla. O Allah befriend with the one who will befriend with him, and be enemy with the one who is his enemy. And give a victory to the one who will support him, and humiliate to the one who will humiliate him, and make truth with him, where ever he will be”.

And his saying – alayhi salam – “You are for me like Haroon to Moses”.

And his saying: “O Allah bring me the one who you love most, so he can eat with me this (bird)”.

SubhanAllah! These 3 reports that used by shias like so called 101% clear proofs for Ali imamah, are HIDDEN, MEANING NOT CLEAR PROOFS for his Imamah!