Ali al-Milani commented on shia scholars which believed in tahrif


هل صحيح هو قول الشيخ المفيد وأبو الحسن العاملي والسيد نعمة الله الجزائري والمجلسي وغيرهم ـ مع ما لهم من الفضل والدرجة العلمية الرفيعة ـ بتحريف القرآن ؟
ج 4 : نحن لا ننكر وجود عددٍ قليل جداً من المحدّثين عندنا يقولون بنقصان القرآن الكريم ، وكونه قولاً مردوداً لا يقدح بالدرجة العلمية للقائلين به ، ولا يجوّز لنا الطعن فيهم

http://www.alquran-network.net/masael2.htm

Translation:

Question 4: Is it true the saying of Shaykh Mufid, and Abul Hasan al-Amili, and Sayyid Ni’matullah al-Jazairi and Majlisi and others- in spite of their virtues and high position- that there was Tahreef in the Quran?

Answer 4 (answering Milane): We do not deny the existence of a very few from among our Muhaddethin about the deletion of the Holy Quran, and this saying is refuted but it is not allowed for us to disassociate ourselves from them.

As you can see this ayatolla didn’t deny that above mentioned scholars did believe in Tahrif.

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 854 other followers

%d bloggers like this: