Category Archives: Shia VS Quran

True Quran is with Mahdi!

Posted on by

as Salam Alaykum.

Book: al-Maalimul Aqidah.

Author: Shaykh al-Haydar al-Wakeel.

p 45 (screen shot):

“6-عقيدتنا في القران 

و القران هو الكتاب المنزل من الله تعالى على نبيه و رسوله محمد بن عبد الله ( صلى الله عليه واله) في ثلاث و عشرين سنة و فيه علم كل شيء مما يحتاجه الناس يعرفه اهله الذين انزل القران في بيوتهم و فيه اصول العقيدة الحقة و فروع الاحكام و بيان و هدى للمتقين .
و ما بين الدفتين قرآن لم يُزد فيه و الظاهر من طريقة جمعه ان فيه تغييرا في مواضع بعض الايات .

و قرآن علي هو القران كما أُنزل دون ادنى تغيير و هو عند الائمة الهداة(صلوات الله عليهم ) و يُظهر صاحب العصر الامام المهدي (صلوات الله عليه ) عند ظهوره و ينصب الفساطيط لإصحابه يُعلمون القران كما أُنزل . “

  – 6. Our faith in Quran.

“And Quran is a book revealed from Allah upon his messenger and prophet Muhammad ibn Abdullah (sallalahu alayhi wa alihi) in 23 years. And it contain all things needed to people, which known by its family, in which house been revealed Quran. And in it foundations of true faith, and branches of rulings, statement and guidance to the righteous. And between the two covers is Quran, and there is nothing added there. Apparent from the method of (Quran) collection that there is a change in the positions of some verses. And Quran of Ali is the Quran as revealed without the slightest change, and it is with Imams of Guidance (salawatullahi alayhim). Owner of century imam al-Mahdi would reveal this (Quran) upon his appearance…”

 

Ibn Shahrashub and Surah al Wilayah

Posted on by

In the book “al-Mualam al-Ulamah” of ibn Shahrashub (p 257 on the right of the scan) written: (799) Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Shahrashub author of this book, he wrote: 1905 – Kitab Manaqib al Abi Talib. 1906 – alMathalib an-Nawasib”.

In the book of Muhammad Hasan l-Ishtiyani “Bahrul Fawaid fi Sharh al-Faraid” (1/475 on the left side of the scan) written: “Yes, from shaykh Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Shahrashub al-Mazandarani in his known book “al-Mathalib”: They dropped from Quran complete surah al-Wilayah“

Ayatollah Shubbar on tahrif

Posted on by

Ayatollah Shubbar in his book “Masabih al anwar”2/295 said:

(القرآن الذي أُنزل على النبي (ص) أكثر مما في أيدينا اليوم ، وقد أُسقط منه شيء كثير ، كما دلت الأخبار المتظافرة التي كادت أن تكون متواترة ، وقد أوضحنا ذلك في كتابنا : منية المحصلين في حقيقة طريقة المجتهدين)

Translate:

“Quran which is was revealed on messenger (sallalahu alayhi wa sallam) was bigger than the one which is on our hands today. Lots of things been dropped from it, like it was proved by concerted reports that almost reaches level of mutawatir. We made this clear in our book “Munyatul Muhsilin fi Haqiqat Tariqat al-Mujtahidin”.

Hoor al-Amili on Tahrif

Posted on by

Famous and known shia scholar Hoor al-Amili in “Fawaid Toosiyah” (p 483, scan page) said:

وقد تواترت الروايات بأنه لم يجمع القرآن كله الا الأئمة عليهم السلام وان من أدعى انه جمعه كله فهو كاذب.
وورد النص الصحيح بأن القرآن الذي نزل على محمد صلى الله عليه واله كان سبعة عشر ألف آية. والموجود الان نحو الثلث باعتبار

Translation:

And there are mutawater reports that no one gathered Quran apart from imams (as), and whoever will claim that he did it, he is liar. And there is sound text that Quran that has been revealed upon Muhammad (sallalahu alaihi wa sallam) contained 17000 verses. And the one which is present is only 1/3 of these numbers.

Tampering book of Abdullah Shubbar “Aslu Asliyah”

Posted on by

as-Salam Alaikum.

1_zpsb5277250 2_zps07b9dd6f3_zps6094a402

These are basically 3 pages (including the cover) of shia book Aslu Asliyah. It was written by famous zindiq Abdullah Shubbar.

On the second page you can see the heading that says: Chapter of obligation to act upon what is present in our hands from Quran (ilal akhir)

On the bottom of the third scan (p 132 from the book), in the footnote you can see comment from editor (I do assume) that said:
كان قبل هذا الباب باب يناسبه، ارتأى كثير من الأفاضل حذفه لكونه محركا لبعض المشاعر
“Before this chapter WAS another one connected to this (by meaning), a lot of distinguished (shias) were upon the view that it should be removed, because (this chapter) was some kind of ignition for some feelings”.

So let me know present for respected members the scan copies of manuscript, where this chapter remained.

01_zps370f3833

As you can see it is chapter:
باب وقوع التغيير والتحريف والنقصان في القرآن
Chapter of the occurrence of the change and distortion and decreases in the Qur’an

And underlined you can see Shubbar quoting book of Kulayni sound shia hadith about 17000 verses in the Quran
So this is a chapter that can “ignite some feelings”. For example feeling of hate from Muslims.

Wa Allahu Alam.
Source: http://alsrdaab.com/vb/showthread.php?t=63493

Prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa sallam) forgot the surah from Quran

Posted on by

Muhadith of shias Sayyed Hashim al-Bahrani narrated in his commentary of Quran – Burhan fi Tafsir al-Quran (p 262):

forgot-1

forgot-2 (1)

(from Imam Abu Jafar (alaihi salam): …. the first surah which was revealed to prophet (sallalahu alaihi wa sallam) is [ 87:1] Glorify the name of your Lord, the Most High – AND HE FORGOT IT!