In the book “al-Mualam al-Ulamah” of ibn Shahrashub (p 257 on the right of the scan) written: (799) Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Shahrashub author of this book, he wrote: 1905 – Kitab Manaqib al Abi Talib. 1906 – alMathalib an-Nawasib”.
In the book of Muhammad Hasan l-Ishtiyani “Bahrul Fawaid fi Sharh al-Faraid” (1/475 on the left side of the scan) written: “Yes, from shaykh Muhammad ibn Ali ibn Shahrashub al-Mazandarani in his known book “al-Mathalib”: They dropped from Quran complete surah al-Wilayah“
Ayatollah Shubbar in his book “Masabih al anwar”2/295 said:
(القرآن الذي أُنزل على النبي (ص) أكثر مما في أيدينا اليوم ، وقد أُسقط منه شيء كثير ، كما دلت الأخبار المتظافرة التي كادت أن تكون متواترة ، وقد أوضحنا ذلك في كتابنا : منية المحصلين في حقيقة طريقة المجتهدين)
“Quran which is was revealed on messenger (sallalahu alayhi wa sallam) was bigger than the one which is on our hands today. Lots of things been dropped from it, like it was proved by concerted reports that almost reaches level of mutawatir. We made this clear in our book “Munyatul Muhsilin fi Haqiqat Tariqat al-Mujtahidin”.
Shia scholar allamah Ali Khan al-Madani ash-Shirazi in his book “Riyadu Salikin” (5/329) said: Continue reading
If you will ask this question to shia scholars, you will be surprised.
Husayn Nuri Tabarsi in “an-Najmu Thakib fi Ahwal Imam al-Hujjatul Qaib” 2/257: Continue reading
as Salam alaykum.
Shaykh of shias ibn Babaweyh in his “Uyun akhbar ar-rida” 1/76: Continue reading
In his book “Faslul Khitab” (p25) Nuri Tabarsi said: Continue reading
as-Salam alaykum, been a long time since last update.
Nuri Tabarsi rafidi muhadith in his famous book “Faslul Khitab fi ISBAT tahrif kitab Rabil ar-Bab” (p 32 manuscript) said: Continue reading